Jump to content
The British Coin Forum - Predecimal.com

Peckris

Expert Grader
  • Posts

    9,800
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    53

Everything posted by Peckris

  1. Despite being of 'rainbow hue', I get the feeling that that coin is naturally toned. I actually like it, as the toning has clearly spread evenly inwards from the edge, which indicates storage conditions to me. A "better price from dipping" is sadly probably true, such is the prevalent ignorance of buyers and the dearth of good old-fashioned dealer advice and education. Worry not, there will be no "dipping" of this coin anytime soon. I like it just the way it is, and I don't really care if it might achieve a better price if dipped. Dipping ruins coins. By definition, it removes surface metal and luster. No thanks! Lightly dipping a toned coin, only removes the corrosion, not metal...the corrosion itself (toning) is what removes the metal.... Heavily dipping (or cleaning) a coin is another matter. I only use the term "dipping" to refer to exposure to an acid solution. No matter how "gentle" or how short an amount of time, the acid solution removes some metal microscopically, particularly at the peaks of the metal flow lines. These peaks are what we see outwardly as luster, and thus dipping actually dampens luster. I have never, and never will "dip" a coin in an acidic solution. That being said, I'm sure I own a few coins that have been dipped in the past -- I just don't want to try my clumsy luck. The only "treatment" I have performed on silver coins is to remove PVC with acetone, with a subsequent rinse in distilled water. Ah, then we've been talking at cross-purposes. When I (and many others) talk of 'dipping', we're talking about proprietary silver dip, such as that sold commercially by Goddards. That might or might not be acid based, but if so it's extremely mild, and after a 10 second dip the coin MUST be rinsed very thoroughly, then dabbed - not wiped - dry. That can expose the underlying lustre on a high grade coin with ugly toning. I've done it! and those coins which have toned back have done so beautifully.
  2. Thank goodness we've broken away from what I still think of as 'indie rock'! But, it doesn't prevent me from posting this
  3. Despite being of 'rainbow hue', I get the feeling that that coin is naturally toned. I actually like it, as the toning has clearly spread evenly inwards from the edge, which indicates storage conditions to me. A "better price from dipping" is sadly probably true, such is the prevalent ignorance of buyers and the dearth of good old-fashioned dealer advice and education. Worry not, there will be no "dipping" of this coin anytime soon. I like it just the way it is, and I don't really care if it might achieve a better price if dipped. Dipping ruins coins. By definition, it removes surface metal and luster. No thanks! By and large I agree. However, I have removed ugly tarnish from silver by dipping for the briefest time (10 seconds), followed by another 10 seconds if the first wasn't enough. That does work, but dipping for any longer ruins a coin, as you say.
  4. That's a very sensible attitude to starting off - curbing impatience until you've learned to grade, and got some idea of what you really want to specialise in (though there's nothing to stop you collecting widely - but sensibly - to begin with, you can always sell off later the items you're not so keen on). I wouldn't be very surprised if it turned out that London Coins do something on those lines - after all, they slabbed and then promoted on eBay some not very special 1915 farthings (VF), so who knows? As it stands, their population reports are pretty meaningless, restricted to what they've actually seen and slabbed. Small picky point : if a Brit says something against Americans or vice versa, they can't be accused of racism. Britain and the US are BOTH composed of different races. Nationalism, is what I think you meant.
  5. Dave's, Tom's, Peter's and mine are all 'inline' videos. (In my case, all I did was copy and paste the address url at the top of the YouTube window.) Everyone else's are clickable links (sorry gents, that's too many for me to chase up).
  6. I think that's a fair point. The problem comes if and when you decide to have your own coins slabbed : the gamble you take in forking out £30 per item, when you're not even sure if the item will be accepted in the first place, makes slabbing anything worth less than £250 raw, not worth it IMO.
  7. I usually don't like toning, but that is a beautiful coin. With that said, the coin would probably bring a better price with a quick dip to remove the color, and restore the coin's natural silver sheen. Despite being of 'rainbow hue', I get the feeling that that coin is naturally toned. I actually like it, as the toning has clearly spread evenly inwards from the edge, which indicates storage conditions to me. A "better price from dipping" is sadly probably true, such is the prevalent ignorance of buyers and the dearth of good old-fashioned dealer advice and education.
  8. Lol, brillant Scott, but watch out, we have a negative investigator on the forum Dave, let it go. (Maybe I should post a new track in the Music topic - Barbra Streisand & Donna Summer "Enough Is Enough" )
  9. On a maintenance grant between £400 - £500 per annum?? It's the same as it's always been. Usefulness doesn't have a unit cost. If you need it, sort it out. Usefulness may not have a unit cost, but if a book costs over 1/8 of your total annual income, it's just not possible economically. Saving for a rainy day? Or thinking ahead as to future expenditure? i.e. not p***ing all your income against the wall. Getting a job in the summer before uni, and every holiday between terms? OK, in my case, my parents and relations always made money available for education, but I still had to save every penny up from any income earned to buy the bike because they refused point blank to contribute. I couldn't afford to do either and that was with full parental contribution. Even if I'd never gone to a bar, bought an album or gone to a rock concert, £60 represented my entire rent for a term (without food or other bills). Luckily our text books only cost a few pounds or I'd have been in sh*t street. Plus, our uni had a library.
  10. How come my (and others') link appears inline as a playable YouTube video, while when others paste a YT url it only appears as a blue clickable link?
  11. On a maintenance grant between £400 - £500 per annum?? It's the same as it's always been. Usefulness doesn't have a unit cost. If you need it, sort it out. Usefulness may not have a unit cost, but if a book costs over 1/8 of your total annual income, it's just not possible economically.
  12. Mmm .. I think I did mention controversy Mynki, though I didn't quite have this in mind! Anyway, welcome to Predecimal and, yes, there are a lot of interesting threads. And plenty of expertise in British coinage, so feel free to ask any questions you like. It isn't always like this I can assure you! Good. I have however been on internet forums or bulletin boards as they were in the beginning for some time. I've seen the best and worst they have to offer many times. I'll look forward to joining in the constructive debates going forward. To summarise very briefly - for US coins, PCGS have a much greater worldwide exposure, for British coins I would go with CGS. Hope that helps.
  13. On a maintenance grant between £400 - £500 per annum??
  14. My understanding (I may be wrong ) is that tokens were not legal tender, but were usually issued by companies and traders for spending on the premises owned by the issuer. Of course, some were issued specifically for collectors etc, i.e. should be regarded as contemporary commems - those quite possibly had no commercial basis whatever.
  15. Ah, the good old "found while out walking" ploy! Conjoined with a "don't no anything about it" - that always gets the enthusiastic semi-informed bargain hunter's pulse racing, as I'm sure the seller knows perfectly well..
  16. waves to the right of the shield differ, a bit like the two types of 1896 halfpenny really need an 1897HT with similar lighting to Bernie's 1926 Cb for a better comparison probably all these designs were kicking around the mint as rejected dies since 1894, Sorry David - I missed your previous post about the 1897 reverse. But it does show that if two people independently had the same thought, it might be worth considering? Meanwhile, can someone answer the question about there being TWO kinds of 1922 ME penny?
  17. I spent an absolute age tracking down a truly UNC 1901 farthing! I still haven't got the full denomination set in UNC (Florin anyone?)!The larger 1901 silver isn't as easy as you might think.
  18. The results will be better if you Google 'Tony Clayton' Nah. Google will just ask "Did you mean Tony Clayton? Showing the results for Tony Clayton."
  19. You could be persuaded to identify that as VicOH rev C from 1897! so if we call that Cb:- Freeman and Gouby die identification now needs a complete rewriteBernies examples added in red Are you saying that 1922 is known with the M.E. and with TWO different reverses? I thought there was only one 1922 ME in existence? On the picture above, is the reverse Cb shown with a small area beyond the rim included on the left hand side? If so, and ignoring that extra bit, I'm thinking that reverse Cb looks rather like the 1897 High Tide reverse - has anyone made a comparison between the two?
  20. I quite agree because believe it or now there is nobody at spink who really knows anything about coins, one of their ex staff freely admitted it ;-)
  21. Those both look very nice scott. What's the date on the Vicky?
  22. The 1965 crowns were issued in very large quantities through the banks and Post Office, so there would have been no cases, just mint bags of crowns for doling out at face value. Some of the 1960 crowns were issued at the special New York Exhibition (so-called 'polished blank' specimens); whether they were before, during or after the regular issue I don't know, but the cases I've always seen for them (and 1953) are the clear plastic slide-top holders that were also used all the way up to the Charles and Di 25p's (and beyond?). Those were not RM issue cases but presumably manufactured en masse by perhaps the same firm that made the Sandhill cases for sets. Because the crown had become a commem-only denomination by 1953, it may have been felt that even the Festival of Britain card cases were too much trouble and expense as people could buy the damn things for face value from banks etc?
  23. In the Beginners Forum.
  24. Very nice! And the only way to get cheap Edward VIII coins. Interesting that it's dated 1936 : some UK coins were already issued dated 1936 for George V, but he died early in the year. UK GV 1936 continued to be issued post-mortem while Edw VIII designs were being prepared and proofs struck. Then there was the Abdication crisis, so all through that GV coins dated 1936 continued to be struck. Then late '36 (early '37?) George VI takes over, and in the rush to mint new coins, most of Edward's designs are lifted lock stock and flipping barrel, including the new brass 3d. The portrait too was hardly touched. That whole 12 months from early 1936 to early 1937, must be a numismatic treasure trove. You could write a whole book on it! (No. I'm not..)
×
×
  • Create New...