Jump to content
The British Coin Forum - Predecimal.com

Peckris

Expert Grader
  • Posts

    9,800
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    53

Everything posted by Peckris

  1. Good to see you again Josie - have a happy Christmas.
  2. You're right - the last circulation crowns were those of Victoria OH type, following the Jubilee Head run. In fact, that itself was a brief restoration, as for most of the 19th Century, crowns weren't produced for currency circulation. You could almost say that 1887-1901 was not typical; it can only be surmised that the crown was a suitable denomination when decimalisation came around, especially after the double florin died an early death. The 20th Century crowns probably didn't circulate, the main problem being that your average tradesman wouldn't be familiar with them and wouldn't have been over-willling to take them. Much more likely is that they were 'pocket pieces' as Copper says - kept by one individual in pocket purse or wallet for long enough, and it would see as much circulation wear as if it had changed hands. Not to mention enthusiastic rubbing as it was showed off to friends.
  3. Welcome to the forum Random Word. What? Can someone run this past Bletchley Park for me please. Ta. Chris must have already purged this 'member' because his original comment has gone! All I can say is, the bots are getting more sophisticated .. they can almost string an incomprehensible sentence together
  4. My dad was a keen amateur genealogist, so we've got his side of the family fairly well sewn up back to the 18th Century. My mum's side is more difficult, more obscure, yet more interesting too - she's done some research but has hit quite a few bottlenecks. The trouble is, her mum died when she was a small child, so the person we called Granny was Grandad's second wife. We know more about that branch than our blood relatives!
  5. Cheers, Paulus...there's a fair bit in there you'd like I reckon!Just looking through it now! Me too. For example he has a simply gorgeous 1806 penny : priced as a Proof; looks like a Proof; but strangely not described as a Proof. Certainly their prices are reasonable
  6. I'm glad you didn't say beaver! Obviously I made a typo and meant to say something completely different, but it's too late to edit now you've quoted me! I believe you - millions wouldn't!
  7. Again I emphasise that I agree with drawing a line...but it is very difficult to do once you start looking into the subject in depth. I find this topic of discussion very interesting, because as a variety collector, and also with my website I find I am constantly reviewing my understanding of micro varieties and parameters for what I consider worthy of inclusion or exclusion. With the above quote from Rob I find it fascinating that most will accept all four digits being cut individually (such as the narrow date pennies) but challenge a variety that is based on the position of a last digit. Why is it acceptable when all four digits are in a different position, but not when the last one has been cut in a different position. There are several examples through the bronze series where the last two digits were positioned, and I could probably dig out examples where three of the four digits may have differing positions....(1879 farthings come to mind)...is that worthy of inclusion? Please don't think I am being pedantic, but it is important for me to get an understanding of where other collectors think the line should be drawn, and I appreciate such a wide range of views...it makes interesting reading In the case of pennies, the so called 'narrow date versions' of 1874, 1875, 1876, 1877 and 1879 are from totally different dies to their normal or wide date counterparts, with other design changes being incorporated too. I don't think these can be considered in the same way as otherwise identical dies, where just the date position is altered. The former are separately listed in Spink and, I believe, should be included in any reasonably detailed price guide. The latter are for specialist publications like Gouby. Edit: I think Rob has just said the same. Yes, that's crucial : the different date spacings in the 1870s pennies are simply the most recognisable feature of what is actually a different design. That's what I meant to say before. The problem with 'small' date is you then get a confusion with the 'penny using halfpenny date punches' realm, which is genuinely small in all dimensions. The 'narrow' date at least has the virtue of being what it says on the tin - 'close spaced' rather than 'wide spaced'.
  8. I'm glad you didn't say beaver!
  9. As numerous as penny collectors are, they still only represent a small fraction of the collecting fraternity - certainly no greater than single figures, and I would hazard a guess in saying that there are probably more decimal collectors than penny ones given the low entry price and the ability to collect from change. It is therefore unreasonable to treat the penny any different to other denominations or periods? Every popular denomination is far outweighed by the numbers of those who don't have an interest in the same, with some alternatives particularly popular. Charles I shillings and halfcrowns spring to mind with most collectors of this type of material aiming to get an example of each Sharp variety shilling, with others aiming for the various initial marks within the group for example along with the halfcrown equivalents. Saxon coinage would be very popular if listed by type and mint rather than the current type listing for the cheapest mint. Given the order of magnitude or greater difference in price for certain rare mints compared to the common ones, this would be instantly comparable to the penny variety listings. The Saxon moneyer/mint combination would be the equivalent 'nerd' detail to those who collect by missing serif for example. Ultimately it is something that is impossible to resolve without making a paper tome that would be impractical in size and weight. That is why I think the basic references should be kept as simple as possible with the minor varieties covered by a denomination specialist reference. What, no more than 9 penny collectors? I think you make some good general points Rob. However, surely varieties in the machine age (post-1797) are more 'significant' to collectors, in that 1) they are more modern and therefore represent more collectors, but 2) any deviation from the 'norm' stands out much more, unlike the numerous punching errors of early milled and the massive unpredictability of individually produced coins of the hammered era? I do think - possibly in vain - that a line SHOULD be drawn however. I think I'm probably among the majority here who would rate the wide/narrow date spacings of bun pennies as significant, and the variations in final digit spacing of OH pennies as not, to give one fairly obvious example.
  10. That's not a moustache, silly. He's trying to eat an armadillo.
  11. ...& the appalling Olivier piece of overblown ham!!
  12. "...goodie goodie yum yum". Watch out for giant kittens and black puddings!
  13. Sheep or not, I think the market dictates what is, and what is not, a collectable 'variety'. And this can change with time, as with the 1961 halfcrown "Designer initials partly or completely missing on reverse" which no longer features anywhere. Now, the 1899 O'NE penny, and the 1946 ONE' penny were both featured on a beginners page in a 60s edition of Coin Monthly, along with a similar raised dot on a Vicky copper penny (I cannot now remember the date). So to me, as a schoolboy, they were well worth looking out for and I pulled a few 1946 ONE's from change. I would now be prepared to pay the right money for an EF example which I've never seen. What is the 'right money'? Well, you find one Rob, and then contact me and I will tell you There may be no 'accepted standard' of what constitutes a variety, but does that matter? The Coin Year Book includes very few. Spink has included more and more over the years. CCGB includes even more. Who's right? The collector and his wallet, to a great extent.
  14. I kind of agree with you on many of the micro varieities, but I think the O'NE should be included. It has been in Sprink for a long time, and has a value of 100-1500 pounds! I agree. And there are serious schools of thought that say it's not a flaw as the dot is too round; they say it's more likely to be a die identification mark of some sort. As for the 1946 ONE' - Gouby always had that, Freeman has it as a note, Spink included it after I nagged them (well, I sent them Gouby's work on it), and it's significant and obvious enough to be collected. Gouby in fact rates it as one degree of rarity higher than a 1926ME!
  15. I'm sure it is! But a 'bot' isn't people, though people certainly created it, for the purpose of making lots of money out of spam and botnets.
  16. I just downloaded the Kindle app for my Mac - it works fine, so that looks like the way for me to go Did you Download the kindle Version Peck or the ePub version, i downloaded the kindle app, but just wanting to make sure which to download I downloaded the Kindle version Dave, but I also had to download the (free) Kindle app for my Mac, also from Amazon. I'm sure there's also a PC version of it.
  17. Not a good idea posting a raw email address in any forum. Admins - do you think you could amend this with an ' AT ' instead of '@' and ' DOT ' instead of '.'? Bots trawl forums like these all the time looking for valid emails among other things.
  18. Link That has to be the worst condition fake I've ever seen!
  19. It's nice to have it on my computer so I can look up prices and varieties for this forum without having to leave my chair First impressions? The digital version is as good as the paper version, perhaps even better as you can click straight to the denomination you want. Second impressions - Chris still hasn't updated 20th Century bronze penny varieties! We have the 1920 unique obverse, 1922/27 reverse, 1933, 1952, 1954 for example, but NOT the 1946 ONE' flaw, the 1953 George VI reverse, or 1911 Gouby X. Still a superb value buy though and WELL worth the money (the Kindle edition is between £4 - £5, how can you go wrong?)
  20. I'd say GVF/EF or NEF/EF. You can probably ignore Spink values (somewhat hyped, I'd say) and rate it somewhere between £150 and getting on for £300. But I may be way out of touch; eBay realised prices may be more accurate, though they are usually less good specimens on there. Here's one with BIN of £169, not quite as good as yours http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/1797-KING-GEORGE-III-CARTWHEEL-TWOPENCE-Good-Example-/390718230395?pt=UK_Coins_BritishMilled_RL&hash=item5af89f0f7b And here's one a bit better, ridiculously overpriced at £675 : http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/1797-TWOPENCE-GEORGE-III-CARTWHEEL-SOHO-ISSUE-HIGH-GRADE/380780901773?rt=nc&_trksid=p2047675.m1851&_trkparms=aid%3D222002%26algo%3DSIC.FIT%26ao%3D1%26asc%3D286%26meid%3D3492024611283833717%26pid%3D100005%26prg%3D1048%26rk%3D4%26rkt%3D5%26sd%3D390718230395%26
  21. I just downloaded the Kindle app for my Mac - it works fine, so that looks like the way for me to go
  22. You may be able to get iBooks from the App Store but I would be very careful to ensure it works under your current operating system. Otherwise, go for the Kindle version. Alternatively, buy a new super-duper Mac. That is what I did after my old one start to go on the blink after 5 years of intensive use. Edit: looks fully illustrated. I have a 2011 Core i5 iMac - that's pretty super-duper! Unfortunately, I'd have to abandon Photoshop (CS2 - one of my 'killer' apps) if I had anything later than Snow Leopard, as it needs Rosetta in order to run. Yep .. that is one of the problems with Macs. That said, on my 2008 Mac (the one I just replaced), I started with Leopard, and upgraded through Lion. My new machine has Maverick but I had no problem loading Photoshop Elements (v 10.0) from my old machine onto the new one. CS2 does appear to be available for later Macs so that might be worth looking at. That's what I'm using. Unfortunately - thanks to the infinite 'wisdom' of Adobe - it's not a Universal Binary but a PowerPC app. In fact, I'd need to upgrade to (I think) CS5 to have a version that will run in Lion or later, i.e. an Intel version. Curiously, Elements 6, which I also have, IS a Universal Binary but sadly it won't support my old scanner which the full Photoshop will, so I need both apps.
×
×
  • Create New...