They are both very nice coins as far as I am concerned.
The "mint wipe lines" do not detract IMHO due to the history (though I had to ask my mate Dr Google what you were on about).
Some info here http://www.australian-coins.com/collecting-coins/great-britain-1902-matte-proof-sets/
Coin-collecting folklore says that the Royal Mint workers disliked the finish greatly and wiped the coins as they came out of the presses on their leather aprons to give them a more brilliant appearance. Regardless of whether the wiping legend is true or not almost every British 1902 proof coin you will find is hairlined, from the monstrous 5 pound coin down to the tiny Maundy penny