Top notch coins. & Croker was a talented man. In the days before internet and pictures in catalogues I used to grade my dealers...Colin was a couple of grades up on some of the others. I only ever sent 1 coin back. G1 is really difficult to grade....don't be too harsh. They rarely fit into Spinks pricing structure eg a typical valuation F £30 VF £125 EF £350....something between a grade is hard to value...and then there is porosity (or lack of),striking flaws,off centres,trace of the dreaded green,weak strikes, etc etc. I would have bought them (with Mrs Peters permission of course)