Colin G. Posted August 1, 2011 Posted August 1, 2011 Did any of the farthing guys on here get lucky with that 1844 farthing on ebay. Great eye appeal, but went way out of my budget range!! http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/1844-NGC-MS63BN-GREAT-BRITAIN-FARTHING-KEY-DATE-/330591727097?pt=LH_DefaultDomain_0&hash=item4cf8cd6df9 Quote
Peter Posted August 1, 2011 Posted August 1, 2011 It would of slotted in nicely but like Bob I hadn't noticed it. It went a bit fierce in the end with only 2 bidders.In hindsight I wouldn't of been in with a chance.I wonder what a 49 1d would make in that condition? Quote
azda Posted August 1, 2011 Posted August 1, 2011 (edited) Maybe the fact that there was only 1 COLON after FID pushed the price farthing boys Betcha didn't notice that till i mentioned it Its ok, the penny man will keep quiet that you farthing boys missed that HUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUGE MISSING COLONNNNNNNNNNNNNNN IN FID Edited August 2, 2011 by azda Quote
RLC35 Posted August 2, 2011 Posted August 2, 2011 You can always tell a variety Man...Good job Azda! After you mentioned the colon, I had to check the one in my album, to see if it has the same missing colon...it doesn't. Mine is only GEF...not as nice as the on on eBay. Quote
Peter Posted August 2, 2011 Posted August 2, 2011 Maybe the fact that there was only 1 COLON after FID pushed the price farthing boys Betcha didn't notice that till i mentioned it Its ok, the penny man will keep quiet that you farthing boys missed that HUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUGE MISSING COLONNNNNNNNNNNNNNN IN FIDWell spotted Dave BUT with the 1838 version of DEF. its value (according to CCGB) is LESS than DEF:Although in my opinion it is scarcer. Quote
Peter Posted August 2, 2011 Posted August 2, 2011 Maybe the fact that there was only 1 COLON after FID pushed the price farthing boys Betcha didn't notice that till i mentioned it Its ok, the penny man will keep quiet that you farthing boys missed that HUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUGE MISSING COLONNNNNNNNNNNNNNN IN FIDWell spotted Dave BUT with the 1838 version of DEF. its value (according to CCGB) is LESS than DEF:Although in my opinion it is scarcer.I will concede on the FID though as the "top" full stop on FID & DEF is faded on mine. Quote
azda Posted August 2, 2011 Posted August 2, 2011 (edited) You can always tell a variety Man...Good job Azda! After you mentioned the colon, I had to check the one in my album, to see if it has the same missing colon...it doesn't. Mine is only GEF...not as nice as the on on eBay.Lol, ONLY GEF Bob, at least you have one. It was a nice looking coin though, was that about as expected for an 1844? Is that also the first time 1 missing Colon has been noted on an 1844? Is Colin going to have to do more variety work on his website now? Edited August 2, 2011 by azda Quote
scott Posted August 2, 2011 Posted August 2, 2011 i have it for 1845 which i dont see listed, if that is the case that it exists for 44 then my 45 FID. might be using that same reverse dye Quote
azda Posted August 2, 2011 Posted August 2, 2011 i have it for 1845 which i dont see listed, if that is the case that it exists for 44 then my 45 FID. might be using that same reverse dyeLol, Colin will be pulling his hair out Quote
Peter Posted August 2, 2011 Posted August 2, 2011 (edited) You can always tell a variety Man...Good job Azda! After you mentioned the colon, I had to check the one in my album, to see if it has the same missing colon...it doesn't. Mine is only GEF...not as nice as the on on eBay.Lol, ONLY GEF Bob, at least you have one. It was a nice looking coin though, was that about as expected for an 1844? Is that also the first time 1 missing Colon has been noted on an 1844? Is Colin going to have to do more variety work on his website now?Well done DaveAs far as I'm concerned that is clear.(not noted by Peck,Bramah,Freeman et all)or me although I haven't studied many (I got a lower grade one many years ago and haven't sought to improve...both top stops are less prominant)My guess before the auction would of been £600.Lets hope 1/4d's don't go the way of Buns Once Colin publishes the market will rocket...and yes if I had spotted the FID.I might have gone to Mrs Peter for a release of funds. Edited August 2, 2011 by Peter Quote
azda Posted August 2, 2011 Posted August 2, 2011 You can always tell a variety Man...Good job Azda! After you mentioned the colon, I had to check the one in my album, to see if it has the same missing colon...it doesn't. Mine is only GEF...not as nice as the on on eBay.Lol, ONLY GEF Bob, at least you have one. It was a nice looking coin though, was that about as expected for an 1844? Is that also the first time 1 missing Colon has been noted on an 1844? Is Colin going to have to do more variety work on his website now?Well done DaveAs far as I'm concerned that is clear.(not noted by Peck,Bramah,Freeman et all)or me although I haven't studied many (I got a lower grade one many years ago and haven't sought to improve...both top stops are less prominant)My guess before the auction would of been £600.Lets hope 1/4d's don't go the way of Buns Once Colin publishes the market will rocket...and yes if I had spotted the FID.I might have gone to Mrs Peter for a release of funds.Well at least you now know that there is a variety of sorts out there for the 1844 and my guess is, that whoever bought it also saw the missing colon which in turn sent the coin spiraling into the unknown. Quote
RLC35 Posted August 2, 2011 Posted August 2, 2011 Attached are pics of one of my 1844 Farthings. In the 10x picture (smaller coin), you can hardly see any of either colon dots. In the 60x pic (larger coin), you can see part of the top dot, but only a whisper of the lower dot. The other colons on the coin are as they are supposed to be. Quote
Colin G. Posted August 2, 2011 Author Posted August 2, 2011 Well at least you now know that there is a variety of sorts out there for the 1844 and my guess is, that whoever bought it also saw the missing colon which in turn sent the coin spiraling into the unknown.I don't think farthings have got to the stage where such a variety would command much of a premium, especially in the copper series.......this is also the problem with cataloguing, it's never ending, and requires you to be very sure before including them in any list. Mine is constantly redefining, but I am slowly getting there....the way it's going maybe by 2020 I will feel comfortable enough to throw it out there Quote
Colin G. Posted August 2, 2011 Author Posted August 2, 2011 Nice Farthing Colin. I hadn't noticed it.It is one of the best 1844 farthings I have seen, I know Colin Cooke's example was lustrous but the reverse was a bit weak and there was a dreaded green spot on the back of the neck. I would have rather have paid 4 figures for that one than the other Quote
azda Posted August 2, 2011 Posted August 2, 2011 So is last nights farthing going to be defined As a variety Colin? Quote
Peckris Posted August 2, 2011 Posted August 2, 2011 So is last nights farthing going to be defined As a variety Colin?My guess is no. The colon dots are notoriously variable and often indistinct on the entire copper series - as so often, is the legend lettering. Even an obsessive would be put off by trying to complete a set of copper with every possible colon dot gradation! An almost infinite series. Quote
£400 for a Penny ? Posted August 2, 2011 Posted August 2, 2011 So is last nights farthing going to be defined As a variety Colin?Can't see why not. At least it's a missing colon - or die wear and not some silly random dot somewhere.Good spot by the way. Quote
Peckris Posted August 2, 2011 Posted August 2, 2011 So is last nights farthing going to be defined As a variety Colin?Can't see why not. At least it's a missing colon - or die wear and not some silly random dot somewhere.Good spot by the way.The missing one, you mean? Quote
Mat Posted August 3, 2011 Posted August 3, 2011 About a year ago a 'finest known' 1844 was on ebay for £5000 buy it now, I think it was slabbed at ms65 but I do not recall it selling, if it did I am sure it would have been an offer outside ebay. Quote
Colin G. Posted August 3, 2011 Author Posted August 3, 2011 About a year ago a 'finest known' 1844 was on ebay for £5000 buy it now, I think it was slabbed at ms65 but I do not recall it selling, if it did I am sure it would have been an offer outside ebay.Must have missed that one!! Quote
VickySilver Posted August 3, 2011 Posted August 3, 2011 Please don't list every filled die variety! I can see somewhat if there is a single central colon , but not one high or low by virtue of the other being filled, etc. Quote
wybrit Posted August 3, 2011 Posted August 3, 2011 About a year ago a 'finest known' 1844 was on ebay for £5000 buy it now, I think it was slabbed at ms65 but I do not recall it selling, if it did I am sure it would have been an offer outside ebay.If it was MS65, it was not one of the two major American grading companies that slabbed it.PCGS only has one - AU55BNNGC has 4: one each at XF40, AU58BN, MS62BN and MS63BN Quote
Colin G. Posted August 3, 2011 Author Posted August 3, 2011 So is last nights farthing going to be defined As a variety Colin?Not at present, but it has gone into the "look out for one" list. I don't like to include them unless there is no doubt, or I have seen an example in hand Quote
Colin G. Posted August 3, 2011 Author Posted August 3, 2011 Please don't list every filled die variety! I can see somewhat if there is a single central colon , but not one high or low by virtue of the other being filled, etc.Not every one that would just blow my mind Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.