Since my coins visit to CGS , it has been toning very well, and its locked in a safe in the dark (but nice and warm as its the server room)
@Sword My coin has the same toning as the top part of yours, was it all that that to start with ?
It was rejected because of toning (Reject: Re-Toned) which I think they mean was cleaned at some time.
It did come back with two extra scratches which I was taking them to court about, but they closed the company just before court case date