Paulus

Is there going to be carnage gentlemen?

Brilliant, thanks Pete @Nonmortuus

Thanks Rob, guess I am just hung up on the word 'tentative' at the moment! They are not at all scarce it seems ...

I have read up on the appropriate BNJ articles and all I can find on-line. Just dipping my toe in the water on these, before even thinking about purchasing, I just have a question about these 'tentative' issues ... were they circulation coins or 'patterns', it is an important distinction to me (for reasons I cannot explain as yet)

Looks like you have transmogrified into mrGOODexample!

Respect Peter, been a while since you posted a new acquisition, that looks a beaut at a great price (less than £39)!

My first attempt at piccing the 1891 through the slab

Many fools ... despite the warning comments!

Great news, nice example!

Thanks Bob, I'd better get me one of those!

Just acquired my first high grade bun penny from Pete ( @PWA 1967) ... an 1891 Gouby BP1891AB graded and slabbed CGS 75. As indicated (by Pete and others) it is much better than the CGS pics suggest, so very pleased. I may try and take my own pics through the slab ...

Like Colin, I use Lighthouse albums with 2x2 adhesive flips, together with a small percentage that are slabbed and in slab boxes holding 20 slabs. These can be locked away in my safe, and it is partly for this reason that I haven't gone for a cabinet (security). I like quality wooden furniture and I have plenty of room for a cabinet. If you are happy with the security aspect regarding your collection, I would go ahead with this one-off purchase - you can also get trays custom made with holes of the diameter you might prefer

Blimey that's interesting Kal, I wonder if there is an alternative theory?

Thanks Pete, I'll take you up on that, email sent

Sorry if this counts as yet another penny thread (which I guess it does), but as a type collector, focussing mainly on milled silver, I also want some examples of other denominations. So my question is, without relying purely on the price guides such as Spink et al, what years are the best to get a type example of an EF+ copper and a GEF+ bronze Viccy penny (with some/much lustre)? To clarify, I am NOT interested in rare dates or varieties ... And if anyone is awash with duplicates to sell that fit the grade, are a fair price, and have no problems, please PM me My only example at the moment is a 1901 with some lustre, too embarrassed to show it though

Your 'hit rate' seems amazing to me George3, are you posting these as you discover them? Also amazed at how you seem to be able to identify them, are you sure this isn't an ancient Aztec fire alarm?

Thanks for the heads up bhx It is certainly cheap at the moment, but bear in mind that this is an auction with 5 days to run, no telling where it will end up!

Hi Colin, great to see you again, and congratulations!

I totally agree - I asked half-jokingly because there was a post quite recently of a TPG assigning 'something over inverted 6' when the known variety was 'over 9' - from memory I think most agreed it was almost certainly a straight forward 'over 9', as I believe this one to be. Can anyone tell me if this variety is now in the new ESC?

Thanks Stu, just wanted to give you something other than pennies to look at! Not 9 over inverted 6 then?

Would people agree that this is 9 over 9 (Davies 89), not listed in Spink or (old) ESC?

Here's some responses to the same question on the CoinsGB Forum back in 2007: http://www.coinsgbforum.com/?showtopic=162 I would imagine that's the same 'Rob' as we know on here!

Shilling is ex Cheshire Collection? Nice one, I look forward to the pics!

Newly acquired, believed to be S. 2337E

It's a lovely coin, GEF for me