Coinery

Will certainly give mine a count tomorrow, could be telling!

Cripes! The only thing is, though, it's still all speculation! I guess the only thing is to buy one dead on the nail weight-wise, with everything else 'right' of course! Where could you buy a genuine top-class Chinese fake of the godless? (without the obvious! )

My two 49's are 11.31 and 11.30, my gothic 11.34! Does anyone have a poor/fine example to hand that they could weigh? I don't think it would be too hard to knock 1/2 a gram or so off a well circulated example! Would certainly be interesting! I did weigh dozens of florins a couple of years ago as part of an exercise in buying scrap silver on eBay! Poor to good fine averaged out at 10.40g-11.25g so I'd guess a 10.80g coin would need to look around fine or less?

Hi Gary, I can't really make very much out from the image quality, apart from the obvious 'patchy tone'! Any more information to go with it? If you click on the link you will see the Ebay listing on the german Ebay. It is from a chinese seller and the description is in english. A Buy It now price of €79. The listing has now ended with no takers A shame though that we can't see it close up and paw over it for the reassurance of all!

what's the weight of your's Dave?

Wouldn't there be slight die variations anyway?

Hi Gary, I can't really make very much out from the image quality, apart from the obvious 'patchy tone'! Any more information to go with it?

With images like that Rodney!

The underlying stress-lines created, by what are immense forces, run deep into the metal of a coin! I know within the last year someone had the images of another coin (I think that may have been a penny too) up on the forum which had suffered the same fate...the underlying stress-lines of the border teeth were the subject of some interesting discussions, as I recall. Would be worth digging it out for a read! It was mine: Ah, there you go bagerap! Damn good forum, this!

The underlying stress-lines created, by what are immense forces, run deep into the metal of a coin! I know within the last year someone had the images of another coin (I think that may have been a penny too) up on the forum which had suffered the same fate...the underlying stress-lines of the border teeth were the subject of some interesting discussions, as I recall. Would be worth digging it out for a read!

I never noticed that! Perhaps that was the point of the bath, some hope of retrieving the underlying 3, such a waste

Looks like a regular penny that's had a long good soak in acid to me!

Ha, ha! He/she wouldn't be able to convince me in a million years that that coin was bent according to his write-up! Nice grade though, if it was cheaper I'd start wondering about chancing two bits of wood and a vice ;-) ! I'm not sure you'd impress too many women today by bending a micro-thin penny!

I'm starting to rather like these myself!

Lodge and beat booked for week of 1st October. 7 days and nights without screaming kids (sadly probably without screaming reels as well but worth it for the peace!). Glenlivet is already stockpiled and order for Cuban cigars about to be placed Glenlivet? Ahh, for that smoky aroma of Talisker, my all time favourite autumnal drink! Ouzo for Greece! My cousins favourite, his description "it's like licking an ashtray" Thanks for that, John! Hopefully I'll be able to put that thought out of my head before I next squeeze the cork out! Now now Stuart, what a man does in the confines of his own home should remain private!

Lodge and beat booked for week of 1st October. 7 days and nights without screaming kids (sadly probably without screaming reels as well but worth it for the peace!). Glenlivet is already stockpiled and order for Cuban cigars about to be placed Glenlivet? Ahh, for that smoky aroma of Talisker, my all time favourite autumnal drink! Ouzo for Greece! My cousins favourite, his description "it's like licking an ashtray" Thanks for that, John! Hopefully I'll be able to put that thought out of my head before I next squeeze the cork out!

I think you all have made some long and interesting points, and I thank you very much for all your time spent. I take every point onboard and confess that I am very quickly infected by the depth it's possible to go to with any type of coin, I do so hope to have the time and resources to one day grab a numismatic dark alley by the horns and shed some light on it! It's got me all o itchin' like a flea-ridden badger!

Lodge and beat booked for week of 1st October. 7 days and nights without screaming kids (sadly probably without screaming reels as well but worth it for the peace!). Glenlivet is already stockpiled and order for Cuban cigars about to be placed Glenlivet? Ahh, for that smoky aroma of Talisker, my all time favourite autumnal drink! Ouzo for Greece! Ouzo? Now you're talking! Just ice!

Christ, should perhaps change his name to Oriental Coin, if he's going to start collecting these types!

Was that a positive feedback then?

Well, it's possible. The problem is agreeing where to stop. If you look at modern coins then differences between one (micro-)variety and another can be down to whether a tooth in the border aligns with a feature or not, or the spacing between the bust and border down to parts of a millimetre. With hammered coins striking quirks, die wear or damage can make two coins struck from the same die look subtly different. Do we count those as varieties, agree that we'll stop at a particular die pairing (Morrieson tried this), or just aim for a general description such as Osborne's (or Sharp or Spink or North ....) I guess it comes down to what sort of collector you are and whether several broadly similar, but subtly different coins is your aim or you are happy to stop at collecting by type or ... Personally, while a portrait/reverse combination I don't have would be a draw, I'm not worried about finding examples of each different privy mark, legend variation etc. I'm just being curious when I ask this question, quite simply because it would appeal to me, and I'm wondering how you might feel about the scenario? I know it would be impractical to collect every single micro-variety, but when you do buy a very nice coin, perhaps from a bad image, is it not your first response and greatest pleasure to get your books out and nail it down as tightly as possible with references? I just wondered whether it would extend the interest and pleasure to follow it through to dies (if it were possible), even though you may well know that the die number catalogued alongside your coin you may never have? Your's however would still have its final resting place, so to speak! I know pinning down dies would be difficult, but I think there could be enough variation to claim 'C below A,' 'E of Rex rotated clockwise and fully joined at the top cross-bar to X' etc? I'm not saying I'm angling to pursue this, just curious to know whether, if such a resource existed, you'd take your shilling collection to the next level, and enjoy doing so?

Thanks for the information, superb stuff, really appreciated! When you say re-engraved dies, are we talking re-worked, as in repaired/updated with puncheons, or did they literally hand-work current dies for betterment? Also, forgive my ignorance, but when it is said there are x numbers known of any coin, where does that information come from, where would I locate such records myself? Thanks again, Stuart

Do you think that might be one of those vintage fairground things, where you can stick your money in a new-fangle-dangle hand-press, with all the wheels and gears on display, and do something exotic to your coin, much like some of the Victorian contraptions at Wookey Hole?

I'm not sure you do. I think there are over 1000 individual dies identified to date, and that's just for shillings. T in C was a huge issue. In fact, everything from Crown onwards with the exception of sceptre was quite prolific. 382 pages. Volume one of .. two? detailing the Tower mint coins. Then there are two more volumes on provincial issues ... and I have a sneaking suspicion that shillings could be just as complex, if not more. So not a work for the faint hearted to attempt. Or even read! Do you think we should stick with the blue cover, Richard, it's quite regal, don't you think?

I just wonder about how it would work to set up an online resource (for any coinage), founded upon the current major numismatic works; basing it on a kind of 'is it a plant,' yes? 'Go to section 4,' etc. type formula? The gaps could then be filled by others, whose coin data could be entered into the database subject to appropriate coins and quality images. Just a future thought!