"M" defect £2 1605 - 2005 Gunpowder plot

[Ethan]

Yes, yes, it says pemember. But what's also interesting is that the "m" on Novemeber is noticeably smaller than the rest.

 

Also the "R" on the November is very clearly a "P" it doesnt even look worn. It seems that the leg of the R just completely didn't print.

 

My question, has anyone else had a coin with the same "m" defect? And also, this coin isnt in brilliant condition. Reasonably, how much do you think this could go for?

[Martinminerva]

These lettering "defects", I'm afraid, are simply the product of how the edge lettering and graining is manufactured: firstly, the blank planchets are incuse lettered by rolling/rotating them under pressure through drums or wheels which contain raised, "mirror" image lettering to impress the correct words into the edge.

Then the lettered blanks are struck between regular dies with a plain, grained collar which imparts the "milling".  And herein lies the problem - metal flow under the significant pressure of the dies where the milling coincides with the incuse letters can produce these anomalies as metal can fill some of the interstices to some or full degree. On your specimen above, the diagonal downstroke of the R is actually still visible, albeit faint, and even full "Pemember" examples are just where the metal flow has obscured that part of the R. Likewise with the M's - they are not a smaller font, just where metal has encroached on the incuse letter somewhat.

A curiosity, yes, but common, yes, and error or variety, no, sorry. And as for value - two pounds, I'm afraid.

[Citizen H]

the crock clip biting to the coin is of concern, I use tweezers that are plastic, rather than metal, .....just an observation,  👍 

[Rob]

1 hour ago, Citizen H said:

the crock clip biting to the coin is of concern, I use tweezers that are plastic, rather than metal, .....just an observation,  👍 

I concur, especially if you were dealing with a mint state piece, which in this state looking at the rims clearly isn't. However, it could be that it was being electropolished to remove crud and toning marks - in which case, a beautification project. As one of ebay's 'must have errors', the condition is probably irrelevant to a great extent. Road kill status is likely to be the biggest impediment to value, when the knocks are impossible to disregard.

[Paddy]

The OP has not been back since his query, and I suspect he won't be as he did not get the glowing response he sought!