Opinion wanted on 1731 6d

[Conor44]

Hi all,

Would appreciate a few experienced opinions on this rather nice 1731 sixpence before I purchase (grade etc) , described as AEF but ive been caught out before with over graded coins. Sorry this is my second post with almost exactly the same wording just a different coin, this is the last one I promise

Thanks in advance,

C44

upload pic

Edited December 12, 2016 by Conor44

[jaggy]

Having compared it with my own example of a 1731 sixpence, I would say it is VF to GVF.

[coinkat]

I would wait for a better example especially  if this is priced at AEF money. 

[Leo]

How difficult is it to find coins of that time without impurities in the flan?

[1949threepence]

I'd say NVF/VF. Also a lot of ding marks on the obverse.

I wouldn't buy it if priced at AEF money. 

[coinkat]

That is a great question. I think clean examples are tough. It's just that this example has hay marking that is severe that adds to factors to consider with grading and even more importantly impacts eye appeal

[Paulus]

I echo some of the opinions above. I would try and find better grade/eye appeal, and if plumping for this one would definitely not pay aEF money for it

[Conor44]

Thanks all, 'dodged a bullet' as it were LOL

Edited December 12, 2016 by Conor44

[Conor44]

Just 'while I'm at it' opinions on this George 1 Shilling ??

[Paulus]

Nice clean example. This is the 2nd bust which is perhaps worth 50% more than the 1st bust ceteris pariba. I'd go "approaching GVF" for grade.

[1949threepence]

about GVF.

[Stuntman]

Sixpence is about VF, Shilling is GVF in my opinion.  A very nice example.  I'd avoid the sixpence but would be very tempted by the shilling if the price seemed fair.

Can I ask who the dealer is?  I promise that I won't buy it.  PM me if easier?