Gothic crown

[SWANNY]

After having my crown marked as reject from CGS , I thought I would look what's around on the market

Found this on Ebay , what do you think of the grading on this coin ?

http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Victoria-Gothic-Crown-1847-Very-Rare-/252140999692?hash=item3ab4c6540c:g:bPkAAOSwI-BWLLfq

[SWANNY]

Then this one , look at the hair just behind the ear on this one , looks strange to me !

http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/RARE-1847-GOTHIC-CROWN-UNDECIMO-BRITISH-SILVER-COIN-FROM-VICTORIA-AU-/361416808966?hash=item54261eda06:g:KmEAAOSwo0JWLkrw

[SWANNY]

And then , look at all these from the USA

http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/iNi-Great-Britain-Gothic-Crown-1847-Beautifully-toned-PROOF-NGC-PF-58-/321898090957?hash=item4af29f11cd:g:gVUAAOSwpDdVX2uS

http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/GREAT-BRITAIN-Victoria-1847-AR-Gothic-Crown-PCGS-PR61-UN-DECIMO-SCBC-3883-/181917117858?hash=item2a5b1aeda2:g:AuIAAOSwo6lWMpps

http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/GREAT-BRITAIN-Victoria-1847-AR-Gothic-Crown-NGC-PR63-UN-DECIMO-SCBC-3883-/171983305809?hash=item280b00fc51:g:AvIAAOSwo6lWMppt

http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/GREAT-BRITAIN-Victoria-1847-AR-Gothic-Crown-PCGS-PR63-UN-DECIMO-Antique-patina-/171955282389?hash=item28095561d5:g:zqsAAOSw4HVWDZb2

http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/GREAT-BRITAIN-Victoria-1847-AR-Gothic-Crown-PCGS-PR63-UN-DECIMO-Antique-patina-/181890282628?hash=item2a59817484:g:flsAAOSwVL1WDZcA

How come the Americans have so many of them.....

[Peter]

Swanny

Get the bugger out of the tomb and resubmit to PCGS or NGC.

Retoned my AR*e

There are 1000'S of fakes made in China.

At least CGS didn't say it was a Chinese takeaway.

You could get good £ on yours.

Hacksaw on CGS coins..... be careful

CGS can be such twats.

[Paulus]

Peter's right, they can display twat-like tendencies.

Here's my example that was rejected for """"Re-toning"""", which I obtained from a very reputable source.

[SWANNY]

I think its such a shame that my coin gets marked "Reject" , and it looks a lot better than most for sale

I,ll get over it , soon.........................

[azda]

I think its such a shame that my coin gets marked "Reject" , and it looks a lot better than most for sale

I,ll get over it , soon.........................

If it's any consolation, I would have bought it myself, it's a decent coin. As Peter says, break it out and send elsewhere if you want to keep it in a slab