Jump to content
British Coin Forum - Predecimal.com

50 Years of RotographicCoinpublications.com A Rotographic Imprint. Price guide reference book publishers since 1959. Lots of books on coins, banknotes and medals. Please visit and like Coin Publications on Facebook for offers and updates.

Coin Publications on Facebook

   Rotographic    

The current range of books. Click the image above to see them on Amazon (printed and Kindle format). More info on coinpublications.com

predecimal.comPredecimal.com. One of the most popular websites on British pre-decimal coins, with hundreds of coins for sale, advice for beginners and interesting information.

Sword

Accomplished Collector
  • Content Count

    2,330
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    111

Everything posted by Sword

  1. I missed that also 🙂 DNW is a well respected auction house. But I think many of us here would agree that the provenance of "Nick's collection" would bear more weight. I didn't bid because I thought (and it turned out quite correctly) that the lots I like are more then I can afford.
  2. Sword

    Possible Fake 1905 Halfcrown

    It's a indeed a very sad incident and I have a great deal of sympathy to the current owner. But the coin is so obviously a fake. It is simply very risky to spend thousands of pounds on the words of a stranger.
  3. I don't think I can be certain even with a better photo. One need to see if there are hairlines and what the luster is like in that area. I would simply ask the seller and see what type of answer you get. Asking about a potential issue can't do any harm even if you want to buy afterwards.
  4. I agree it is possible that area had been wiped in the past.
  5. Sword

    2021 Unc set mystery

    16 weeks wait to get a replacement base pad with enough holes. Not exactly speedy.
  6. Sword

    2021 Unc set mystery

    Even an error in the packaging can only make the set more interesting and there is no reason to return it.
  7. Sword

    BBC articles

    The only "coloured" coin I do like is the 1990 Isle of Man penny black crown. It won three awards at the time:
  8. The serifs on the letters "S" certainly do look different. It's a real shame that someone has removed the possible identification marks on the obverse. It could have given really interesting information.
  9. It is rather unusual that the pattern was struck using worn reverse die. Hence the flatness on St George's chest and helmet. I remember reading somewhere that the 1951 crown was struck using a left over die from the Victorian era with the date altered. Might be someone experimented with a worn old die as an experiment and then a previously unused one was employed for striking the real thing?
  10. Sword

    Mr. Grumpy.

    Haven't heard of it before. Am I alone in thinking that St George's face looks like that of a middle age lady?
  11. Sword

    Mr. Grumpy.

    It's the Royal Mint unfortunately...https://www.royalmint.com/our-coins/events/mr-men-little-miss/
  12. Sword

    Mr. Grumpy.

    Possibly. But my young nephew would be very upset if I brought him that coin instead of a toy he wanted.
  13. Sword

    Mr. Grumpy.

    Not you I think, and definitely not I. A fair number were brought by investors hoping for a quick profit I would imagine. Coins reusing historical designs always have greater chance of becoming wanted at least in the short term. The mint is quite clever not to do this too often or it will lose the effect.
  14. Sword

    Mr. Grumpy.

    Not everyone buying coins are numismatists. They include impulse buyers, investors, misguided investors, souvenir buyers, present purchasers and one-off buyers. The offerings from the Royal Mint are rarely aimed at numismatists these days, but at the other groups. Their mission is to simply to make money (banknotes rather than well-designed coins). It's easier for numismatists to just ignore the souvenir coin market.
  15. Sword

    Mr. Grumpy.

    Just his surname on coins I think.
  16. Sword

    Mr. Grumpy.

    But seriously, it is the norm these days with the Royal Mint. Wallace & Gromit, Paddington, Snowman, Winnie the Pooh ... Described as "uncirculated" and they can never be circulated...
  17. Sword

    Mr. Grumpy.

    "That's not fair! We weren't allowed to put our full names on our designs!"
  18. That's why I really like your example. Well struck fringe and hair band make a big difference to eye appeal. Nice toning and clean fields. The deeper marks (one base of neck and hair) are out of the way and not distracting. The strike is a little weak on the top of the crown on the reverse but this is relatively insignificant. For me, its a definite keeper as it would cost a fortune to upgrade to something significantly better.
  19. This specimen was described as "cut on cheek and other light surface marks, otherwise nearly extremely fine". Sold in 2020 for £360 which went cheap I think. Lower estimate was £500. Finally, this specimen was described as "some surface marks, otherwise good very fine, reverse better". Sold for £300 in 2017.
  20. The next example is described as " few surface marks, otherwise extremely fine or better", sold for £1200 in Sept 2017.
  21. As Eric has pointed out, the weakness of strike does complicate grading of Young Head. For me, eye appeal for this series is as important as grading. Just out of interest, I have been to the DNW website and look at some examples. Then again no auction house's grading is always right or consistent. The example below was graded as GEF, sold for £1350 in 2013 and so would be much much more expensive today. A very impressive specimen.
  22. Is this just a case with some US collectors chasing the highest PCGS grades and paying over the top for the "finest known"? Would the price be a lot less if it say PF66 on the plastic rather than 67?
  23. Sword

    Edward iv

    To be fair, no grade is given on the slab. Someone starting a new grading company. Interesting. Not yet taking any paid business though.
  24. I doubt the prices of coins would come down. Although some people have unfortunately lost their jobs, others are sitting on more money as a result of not able to spend during lock down. Besides interest rate is now so low making saving less attractive.
  25. I don't find Victoria Young Head easy to grade. There is also such a big difference in price for crowns once you get close to EF grade. Nice GVF might be about £400, nice nEF could be £700 and nice EF could be a three figure sum and an UNC example would cost several thousands. The example in the OP is certainly nice in that it hasn't got many contact marks. I have been waiting for a nice example of a young head halfcrown as it would cost too much to get the more impressive crown.
×