Jump to content
British Coin Forum - Predecimal.com

50 Years of RotographicCoinpublications.com A Rotographic Imprint. Price guide reference book publishers since 1959. Lots of books on coins, banknotes and medals. Please visit and like Coin Publications on Facebook for offers and updates.

Coin Publications on Facebook

   Rotographic    

The current range of books. Click the image above to see them on Amazon (printed and Kindle format). More info on coinpublications.com

predecimal.comPredecimal.com. One of the most popular websites on British pre-decimal coins, with hundreds of coins for sale, advice for beginners and interesting information.

copper123

Coin Hoarder
  • Content Count

    3,548
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    99

Posts posted by copper123


  1. Yes, but we merely pointed out he was wrong, and he went ballistic about it, with coins it's a variety or not a variety or a grade or not a grade nothing else matters , some on here have spent years grading coins and are about fit enough to work for a slabbing company (not that I want anyone to start on that slippery slope).

    Buying a book and studying for half an hour will not be enough to get you anywhere near the grading standards of the experience collectors on here.

    He should be heeding what we say and learning from us and not just throwing his toys out of the pram , because he does not like what we have to say


  2. I know Lawrence Chard used to stock silver medals and Bob Ilsley of Dolphin (now Three Counties Coins) some South African coins etc. Might be worth contacting either of them?

    However, my guess is that however much the medallions were marketed or sold for originally, if you can't find much evidence of demand for such a set then close to bullion would be a reasonable starting point. You don't say if you're looking to buy or sell, but if the latter maybe add on a bit to the BV for the fact its a set and no doubt looks nice and see what interest you get?

    As it says on Chard's website: The secondary (secondhand) market prices for silver medallions is usually quite competitively priced, and for connoisseurs of medallic or numismatic art, previously owned medallion sets often represent a bargain especially compared with the original new prices.

    In other words, these things cost a fortune when issued with promises of 'investment potential' but when it comes to selling they don't realise anything like as much.

    :(

    .

    In other words - don't believe the bullshit


  3. I find it strange he went mad and said I was wrong with the coin being cleaned , unless he is 135 years old (very unlikely) he will not have been the only person to own the coin so how can he state categorically that it's never been cleaned .

    In fact the coin looks like its been cleaned a good seventy or eighty years ago and is toning down so it has not affected the value that much to most collectors maybe knock 33% off


  4. As numismatics is concerned decimal coins will never be scarce or show a great profit , I must admit in the last ten years or so it's got far more interesting with commems being fired out right left and centre.

    I think this bodes well for the coin collectors in the future as really the age of the average collector these days is prob around 55 years old and the hobby will die without new blood.

    I suppose things like the publicity around the undated 20p and kew gardens 50p can do little long term harm and more good than anything really.

    Sixties and seventies crowns did little for the hobby in the long term , in fact putting many people off putting money into coins for life (remember the bags of Churchill crowns marketed as an investment)


  5. I think many American coins are really lovely V nickles, wheat cents, buffalo nickles, and those huge silver dollars which are really quite cheap due to plenty being around,the gold esp. the early stuff is very attractive and make you think of the wild west. I must admit the prices of rarities are around 100 times more than a similar English french or German coins

    Overall though I am happy to collect UK coins.

    • Like 1

  6. I would have a guess at around a hundred - but it could be far less.

    More and more will come to light in coming years .

    I suspect this variety might be worth around £300 in a few years time as more and more finds are made, and the novelty fades away

    There again i thought that undated 20p coins would be worth £5 now and they still fetch £30 so I could easy be wrong - it's not an exact science

    • Like 1

  7. my grandads were inscribed on the edge , or just the silver one was he was an ord tommy in the royal marines - not sure if he had to pay extra for that.

    By the way ist WW medals were superbly struck though it is rare to see one these days that has not been well cleaned.

    English WWW1 medals are often called Pip squeak and Wilfred , after a popular cartoon in a national newspaper I think

×