Jump to content
British Coin Forum - Predecimal.com

50 Years of RotographicCoinpublications.com A Rotographic Imprint. Price guide reference book publishers since 1959. Lots of books on coins, banknotes and medals. Please visit and like Coin Publications on Facebook for offers and updates.

Coin Publications on Facebook

   Rotographic    

The current range of books. Click the image above to see them on Amazon (printed and Kindle format). More info on coinpublications.com

predecimal.comPredecimal.com. One of the most popular websites on British pre-decimal coins, with hundreds of coins for sale, advice for beginners and interesting information.

celtic_coin

Unidentified Variety
  • Content Count

    31
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    1

Everything posted by celtic_coin

  1. As the title. Jon Blyth seems to apply the price of 1893 Jubilee head threepence on the price of 1893 veil head threepence. The coin is at least eight times overpriced. https://jonblyth.com/coins/coin-details.aspx?id=2561
  2. https://jonblyth.com/coins/coin-details.aspx?id=2501 The 1728 shilling ms63 for 2500 pounds is reserved, while the fair price is about 1250 pounds...
  3. That is why for quality coins and rare coins I tend to be more luxury when bidding in the auction. Otherwise they will end up in the hands of "dealers" like Jon, which will turn up with a price I cannot afford.
  4. And 1887 business-strike Jubilee head florin for 1250 pounds while 125 pounds are the reasonable price https://jonblyth.com/coins/coin-details.aspx?id=2480
  5. In Numistacker's new video, the title is "new pattern coins from 1953, 1901 and 1902", while those are not "pattern coins", those are fantasy coins.
  6. Numistacker has stated in a video that he and Jon Blyth are friends. You can tell that from John's website.
  7. The problem of John Blyth is, he is trying to sell the slab, not the coin.
  8. celtic_coin

    Spink auction today

    The series E Variety C type I acquired is not rare, but it is rare to have a bird motif. The coin is also in good condition.
  9. celtic_coin

    Spink auction today

    The auction is extremely hot – prices of high-quality coins are far more expensive than the estimate. However, I found it much more reasonable than auction of milled coin and later hammered coin – a large collection of early anglo-saxon coins can be unique, and early anglo-saxon coins of good condition are extremely difficult to find on the market. I only manage to get one lot: https://live.spink.com/lots/view/4-1TK3W3/anglo-saxon-england-continental-series-695-740-sceat-series-e-variety-c-crescent-enclosi
  10. celtic_coin

    Slabbing

    Indeed. Tin coins would be the same. It is extremely difficult to store tin coins without slabbing. I have purchased https://live.spink.com/lots/view/4-15AC0V/mint-state-63-colonial-america-james-ii-1685-88-plantation-token-of-124-reale-1688-in-tin this coin from the hardcastle sale, and slabbing this gem is definitely necessary and brilliant. Information of this coin: https://coins.nd.edu/ColCoin/ColCoinIntros/AmPlant.intro.html
  11. celtic_coin

    Slabbing

    My previous post is related with the topic: the Numistacker is so depended on slabbing that he does have a very limited knowledge regarding grading coins. Any experienced coin collectors would grade this as NEF, while he thought he has bought a UNC proof.
  12. A video of Numistacker that is interesting. Some highlights: In the video he said that 1700 pounds is the right price for a 1821 proof crown, while nowadays a 1821 proof crown should cost at least 3000 pounds. If it is really a uncirculated 1821 proof crown, it worth about 5000 pounds. The highlight of the video is: he thought he has purchased an uncirculated 1821 proof crown, while any experienced coin collectors would grade this coin as NEF based on the photo of the coin.
  13. The story of Regal Stacker continues. He just listed some new items. His ebay "store": https://www.ebay.co.uk/sch/thesovereignclub/m.html?_nkw=&_armrs=1&_ipg=&_from= Here are some "highlights": https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/1980s-Elizabeth-11-Gold-Sovereigns-All-Years-All-PF70-Ultra-Cameo/333912991236?hash=item4dbec3e604:g:Dr8AAOSwbmJgRO2K https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/1990s-Elizabeth-11-Gold-Sovereigns-All-Years-All-PF70-Ultra-Cameo/333912988825?hash=item4dbec3dc99:g:lmEAAOSwDVBgRPJy https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/1893-Queen-Victoria-Proof-Florin-2-Shillings-PR67DCAM/333911665857?hash=item4dbeafacc1:g:9J0AAOSw6N1fnuyC Prices of his item are much more than outrageous. The prices he listed are three times or more expensive than prices realised in main auction houses, and maybe four times or more expensive than the fair prices. Rusell Franks (also known as the Numistacker) and Regal Stacker. You know they are good friends when you visit Regal's ebay "store".
  14. Recently I acquired a unique 1696 sixpence from an auction house in UK. The coin is a 1696 sixpence (First Bust, early Harp variety), but the coin is significantly double struck. The coin is graded by ngc as MINT ERROR MS 65 DOUBLE STRUCK. I have seen double striking in 17th early milled coin, but very few of those error coins can survive in a real uncirculated condition. What is more, the degree of the double struck is significant. I am not sure if I can consider my coin as a new variety of 1696 sixpence, but this coin is definitely unique. Here is the photo of my coin (the first taken by auction house, the second and the last by myself).
  15. celtic_coin

    1953 VIP Proof set

    I agree with you. It is indeed a superb set, and the coppers do catch my eyes, too. For this set, it is worth grading, and 200 pounds is bit low for this set. However, for the price the seller asks… it is crazy high.
  16. celtic_coin

    1953 VIP Proof set

    Sorry for repeating comment; I do not know how to delete this one.
  17. celtic_coin

    1953 VIP Proof set

    Confirmed -- Regal stack just promote the set on his youtube. So the set is directly sold by him.
  18. celtic_coin

    1953 VIP Proof set

    Rusell Franks is the Numistacker, and he is also the CEO of infinity (the 'office' address on Numistacker website is identical to the ifinity). The set was sent to ngc graded via Numistacker, by a guy whose nick name is regal stacker. Not sure if the coin was purchased by someone from regal stacker, then resale it or directly sell by regal stacker).
  19. celtic_coin

    1953 VIP Proof set

    The DNW one seems reasonable compare to a set on ebay. This set is "featured" on Russell Franks (https://twitter.com/russellfranks also known as numistacker)'s youtube channel, which is completely a scandal. I will pay maximum 200 pounds for the set, while on ebay the list is 5990 pounds. What a scandal! https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/1953-Proof-Elizabeth-11-Coronation-Set-Finest-Graded-by-NGC/333897621417?_trkparms=ispr%3D1&hash=item4dbdd95fa9:g:eoUAAOSwgiZfizV7&amdata=enc%3AAQAFAAACcBaobrjLl8XobRIiIML1V4Imu%2Fn%2BzU5L90Z278x5ickkCrLl8erj3ATP5raQxjc%2F%2B%2BRiRdjR4cOHiNowP93xMlN1VTBD5JYspSQThr9Sl9FkxJMCr%2Fdk%2FoiQI16fUdilQClNp8ECWg7ERXzTUtpWB1yP9DU%2FYyXvmt9lP53K8mL1pyfwU5lKwA0AwffzK8E7yVlITyRXTNzRhxuCM9Sz0XJHPnkfAmAXbSP%2BWGB25Yx1oodfT0K9Z498Nh79xY6qNl9F%2B95tq5GRwwBlAWipp9gOnOQGbYrvVG9SUY7Cqv6pJZIF7IPLSh%2FtaH71PARn4t%2FtSioaIvfs2yP7bZJMSdA%2FpsXpEVeyyLKD6tQz0Tn%2BDlKHnjnOQI1Lt1wNIaLHdl0vIQ3%2FQ7aPRV6Kleex6I3FZBsdV%2BYI696BcnC5ACxqlQXtdgzxK4vWN6zVrWEAjYgtyq9%2BHOSYR9fIZUMJBE%2BRLgl9efSfiv7xF%2FJ1oRf2HJ1J%2FeJg2qL08%2BTrvo0e7abh5XK4pEIBpcDXB8RWDEJ1XO5Uptott%2BHGX54g%2Bm2hdCt9iA6xu7FD%2FcKIc331CSWRahmsRSJHcx%2BBGtFoI9NA4V96QzOVX6quQZcIyN7mx1E6JW6mm%2BMzJ%2FXqvCR3jWJHxS1pzaveiFDKnVb%2FKcYfR%2BXlMCIsM%2BoI4RpuNlSqGEQWEBR5eTuNVZsx7yPqVYvW5ClkSKQ6Ldq%2Fi1RgBf274twL%2Far6f599xGKNnx1Zx2JNZ%2B982dqfJpf1VSTG4joG8MPdD0Iakfi94W2ooJ2BeEEV4ryZKOi3%2FC%2Bggu5rGzNYbiFt7VDK0HVc%2FBe2vA%3D%3D|cksum%3A33389762141781788561768846659b34161d3e36011d|ampid%3APL_CLK|clp%3A2334524
  20. I acquired the 1732 half guinea, graded by pcgs as AU55 coin from the Spink e-circular on last Wednesday. With the buyer premium added, it cost me around 2100 pounds, and I am very happy to add this gem to my collection. All George II Young head half guineas are extremely rare and this one is possibly the best condition available for 1732 half guinea. Thanks to the Spink, lustre of the coin does not appear on the photo taken by them , so I purchase this coin slightly behind "fair price". This kind of rare coins can easily go far more expensive than "fair price". For example, a au58 1731 guinea(as we know, price of 1731 half guinea and 1732 guinea are similar for the similar condition) sold for 6000 pounds in the spink auction of last September ( https://live.spink.com/lots/view/4-URIJO/ngc-au58-george-ii-1727-1760-half-guinea-1731-ex-douglas-morris) If Photo of the Spink is of high quality and professionally taken, or private viewing is allowed, I would not be able to buy this gem at this affordable price. Sometimes photo of the spink can be unprofessional, for example, the 1703 Vigo crown sold in the Erik Miller sale. After the auction, it is sent to ngc for grading and auctioned in the heritage. If you compare two photos, you will not believe they are two photos taken on the same coin. (https://live.spink.com/lots/view/4-OROJ/anne-1702-1714-crown-1703-tertio-draped-bust-left-vigo-below-rev-crowned-shields-crucif and https://coins.ha.com/itm/great-britain/great-britain-anne-vigo-crown-1703-ms65-ngc-/a/3081-32205.s) Photo of my coin (photo 1 and photo 2 are photos from this auction; photo 3 is the photo from the 2005 Coinex auction; photo 4 and photo 5 are taken by myself):
  21. celtic_coin

    Ebay's Worst Offerings

    https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/ELIZABETH-II-1953-PROOF-CROWN-NGC-PF66-CAMEO/203284555600?hash=item2f54b42750:g:CnwAAOSwE3Bf34aq And this one. Nowadays for 1953 proofs, a lot of sellers would sell a cam one as vip proof, which is completely a scandal.
  22. celtic_coin

    Ebay's Worst Offerings

    I just saw this 1862 shilling sold by jonblyth for 940 pounds -- while Mark listed it for 450 pounds (ref23/164). I do wonder why some collectors only keep an eye on the ebay. (that coin should be directly purchased from mark by Jon, he then sent it for grading and hold it for some time. ) https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/1862-Queen-Victoria-Great-Britain-London-Mint-Silver-Shilling-Coin-1S-NGC-MS63/363297542820?_trksid=p2485497.m4902.l9144
×